New Ohio Valley Wrestling Tag Team Champions were crowned on November 12, 2019 on OVW Television episode 1057.
The 2019 Nightmare Cup winners Dimes and Corey Storm cashed in their title shot on OVW TV against the Legacy of Brutality. While the Legacy enjoys a numbers advantage anytime they compete, referee Dave Harmon evened the odds before the contest by ejecting anyone without a manager’s license from ringside. That left Jay Bradley and Ca$h Flo with only Legacy of Brutality manager Josh Ashcraft in their corner.
Bradley and Flo still had their size advantage, which they used mercilessly against Corey Storm and Dimes throughout the match. Storm and Dimes were outgunned by the larger, dominant champions but soon displayed the heart and athleticism that won them the Nightmare Cup.
With television time running out, the Legacy devastated Dimes and Storm and were on their way to a successful defense. However, the challengers rallied back to win the championships in an exhilarating overtime finish.